Games · Make

Design a cooperative paper puzzle

Which rule makes two fictional roles useful without requiring competition?

Build a shared-goal puzzle in which two fictional rule cards contribute different information.

10–20 minutes, or one small comparison for a first try. More time is optional.

Rule A requires circle before triangle. Rule B requires square in slot 2. The combined answer is circle, square, triangle. Changing B to square first gives square, circle, triangle.
Original model: two rules, one arrangement. Open full-size diagram ↗

Start here

Draw three tokens: circle, square and triangle, with three empty slots in a row.

Use your idea or the example below. Talk, write, draw, point or listen first. You can stop after one step.

Try it your way.

  1. Set a shared goal

    The aim is one arrangement satisfying both rules. Role A’s card says circle before triangle; Role B’s card says square in the middle.

  2. Combine the clues

    The square takes slot 2. The circle must be before the triangle, so place the circle in slot 1 and triangle in slot 3.

  3. Choose how to play

    You can read both role cards yourself, take turns with a mentor, or simply discuss the solution. No hidden information or partner is required.

  4. Revise one rule

    Change the second card to square first. Keep circle before triangle. Find the new order and explain which placement changed.

One possible version

Original model: two rules, one arrangement

These fictional roles organise a paper puzzle. No claims about social-skill improvement or participant responses are made.

  • Rule A: circle before triangle. Rule B: square in the middle.
  • Both together give circle, square, triangle. With square fixed in the middle, only that order has circle before triangle.
  • Changing only B to square first gives square, circle, triangle.

A one-solution token puzzle does not establish how all cooperative games work. Information can be shared openly if that suits the learner.

A different way.

Point to drawn tokens, speak the order, or direct someone else to number the slots. One person can use both roles.

If you want more.

Remove the middle-slot rule and count how many arrangements still keep circle before triangle. Check all six orders if you want.

Something to keep?

Which part of the solution depends on each rule?

You can keep a question, a sketch or a change of mind. A finished product is optional.

This opens an editable starter in your project tools. It asks before replacing open work. Choosing it does not save or share your work automatically.